LPL wins, Raymond James loses in billion-dollar branches' big moves

Private Advisor Group and AK Financial Group
Private Advisor Group and AK Financial Group held a gathering in Irvine, California, last week ahead of announcing AK Financial's move to Private Advisor. From left to right in the back row: Stan DiLiberto, Val Simson of Badger Financial Group; Tori Patrick of Progressive Strategies; RJ and Sarah Moore of Private Advisor Group; Ross Lang of New York Life, James Sullivan, Garrett Friedrich, Anne Mortera and Kelly Coulter of Private Advisor Group. From left to right in the front row: Andy Karlinski, Roderick Uy and Kara Brooks of AK Financial Group.

The complicated ties between independent wealth managers and their biggest branches are working for both sides in one major firm's case and falling apart in that of another.

Concurrent Advisors — and its 145 financial advisors with $12.7 billion in client assets — will drop Raymond James Financial Services as its brokerage and leave Raymond James' custodian next year, according to statements from the firms this week. Since receiving a minority equity investment last year from Merchant Investment Management, Concurrent has added 25 advisors with $3.4 billion in client assets through its recruiting in 2022. The firm now plans to follow a different billion-dollar enterprise, Steward Partners, that already left Raymond James' brokerage this year.

In contrast, Raymond James rival LPL Financial and one of its biggest branches, Private Advisor Group, are retaining business with plans to expand under a recruiting and succession move by AK Financial Group. Merchant invested in Private Advisor last year as well. Just like Private Advisor, AK Financial's 21 financial advisors with $1 billion in client assets use LPL as their primary brokerage and a custodian. They'll launch Private Advisor's first corporate office on the West Coast out of AK Financial's current home in Irvine, California, the firms said last week.

The parties' joint long-standing relationships with LPL, succession of 45-year veteran AK Financial founder Andy Karlinski's firm and the need to reduce operational headaches prompted him to choose Private Advisor, Karlinski said in an interview.

"I am now reducing — which is wonderful — my regulation and compliance time and effort," he said. "It's an exciting business. It's booming, but it's just going to go nowhere but up. I'll be doing mentoring. I'll be doing recruiting."

By getting rid of its own registered investment advisor in the process of moving into Private Advisor, Karlinski's firm is removing a layer of complexity in the structure of independent wealth managers adopting an array of different models that have proven successful in recent years. Financial advisors choose among many outside firms angling to be service providers as branches, brokerages or custodians. Some advisors have created their own brokerages by breaking off from the giants, while others use third-party companies that support the business.

For example, Atlanta-based Advisory Services Network uses an outside brokerage called Calton & Associates that co-founder Tom Prescott describes as filling a need to service certain products among the roughly 225 advisors with $5.8 billion in client assets at the RIA. Advisory Services Network hasn't taken any outside capital infusions and doesn't buy any practices, either, which is another area of difference with many RIAs recruiting advisors these days. The prospective recruits can pick among many types of firms. Indeed, Advisory Services finds new advisors seeking limited brokerage relationships or none at all after working for firms like Raymond James and LPL, Prescott said in an interview.

"Practices join us for the economy of scale and for the platform," he said. Advisory Services' approach to working with advisors "gives them more time to speak to their clients and grow their books."

Tampa, Florida-based Concurrent is making a major change to its structure that isn't entirely clear. AdvisorHub first reported that the branch launched an RIA last month and plans to stop using Raymond James as a brokerage. 

Neither has said what, if any, brokerage Concurrent will use after leaving Raymond James in a departure slated for the first quarter of next year. The new RIA's registration with the SEC lists Charles Schwab and Fidelity's custodians, though Concurrent co-founder Nate Lenz said in an email that the firm is "currently evaluating multiple new custodial relationships." As for the brokerage aspect of the business, Lenz said the firm is speaking with "leading broker-dealers right now" and expects to select one of them in coming weeks.

An even bigger branch than Concurrent, Steward Partners, already had its own RIA in May when it made a similar move to leave the Raymond James brokerage. In a different twist to Concurrent, though, Steward Partners retained Raymond James as one of its RIA custodians. Concurrent and Raymond James haven't said what's leading them to part ways completely. 

"Raymond James has decided to end its relationship with Concurrent Advisors and is in discussions with the branch owners regarding an orderly dissolution of our relationship," Raymond James spokesman Justin Mayfield said in a statement. "Consistent with Raymond James' values and commitments, we will support those advisors who want to transition with Concurrent as well as those who wish to remain directly affiliated as independent contractors with Raymond James."

Under its eventual new setup in 2023 as an RIA with multiple custodians, Concurrent is seeking to reach $15 billion in client assets by the end of next year through recruiting and M&A deals.

"Our team and the advisors we support should be proud of the great work we have achieved so far," Lenz said. "The success we have earned together made it possible for us to pursue the next stage of our growth at a time when advisors need every advantage to outpace a volatile environment and guide their clients to better outcomes."

Concurrent is pivoting toward an its own advisory firm using several custodians — the same RIA arrangement as Advisory Services and Private Advisor. The ability to work with more custodians enables the firms to work with a wider base of advisors, which is just one of the ways that wealth managers are displaying more flexibility as they recruit across the industry.

Private Advisor, a Morristown, New Jersey-based firm with 700 advisors and $33 billion in client assets, made the largest acquisition in its history in March and launched its Advisor Alignment and Equity Program earlier this year to provide consulting and financing to the branch's practices. While the fact that AK Financial was also using LPL as its brokerage "limits disruption" and illustrates the "further alignment" with similar potential incoming teams, Private Advisor is seeking out new recruits from any firm, President Frank Smith said in an interview. That group includes advisors who don't want to work with any brokerage at all.   

"The profession right now is very much focused on talks around transactions, valuations and liquidity," Smith said. "We're in a position we're we can help a lot of firms."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Industry News Recruiting RIAs LPL Financial Raymond James Financial
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING